The University Bookman

 
 

Fall 2017

Books in Little: The Disaffected

book cover imageThe New Minority: White Working Class Politics in an Age of Immigration and Inequality
by Justin Gest.
Oxford University Press, 2016.
Paper, xiii + 249 pages, $24.95

Robert Grano

The past year or so has seen the appearance of quite a few books dealing with the white poor and the white working class, beginning with the unexpected success of J. D. Vance’s much-discussed Hillbilly Elegy. Naturally some of these have been more helpful and insightful than others, but The New Minority by Justin Gest stands out in that its analysis is based upon a sociological study undertaken by the author himself in an attempt to get to the root of white working class disaffectedness and radicalization.

Gest, an assistant professor of public policy at George Mason University, surveyed hundreds of residents of two white working class areas—Youngstown, Ohio in the U.S., and the East London boroughs of Barking and Dagenham in England. He also did face-to-face interviews with many residents. The results of his research, while showing that in some instances there are differences between the white working classes of the two countries, demonstrate a deeper commonality: the belief that they are being marginalized, and that no one in power cares. Gest shows that while in many instances this marginalization has an economic component, a racial component, or some combination of both, the underlying complaint is that of the loss of attentiveness to their concerns on the part of politicians.

While a notable lessening of political power obviously comes in to play, in that a group that once represented a majority does so no longer, Gest’s study illustrates that, pace the views of certain progressives, it is not that alone which constitutes the white working class’s feeling of marginalization. It is not the “loss of hegemony” per se that disturbs them, but the feeling that they no longer have any political influence at all, even regarding concerns that affect them directly.

The New Minority was published before the 2016 U.S. election, so it mentions Donald Trump’s candidacy only in terms of his growing success among the various GOP candidates. But it does point out a fact that Trump’s opponents, both Republican and Democratic, were to regret later: he was the one who listened (or at least pretended to listen) to the white working class. Which if Gest’s analysis is correct, was, at bottom, all it really wanted. He “addresse[d] people who felt silenced” and “bluntly acknowledged white working class people’s acute sense of loss.”

Gest closes the book with suggestions for both liberals and conservatives on how the white working class can be appealed to in the future. He notes the difficulty in doing so, however, given the Democrats’ “reluctance to risk their relationship with more socially liberal and diverse voting blocs” and the Republicans’ inability to harmonize their “establishment” and “anti-establishment” strains. While these various conflicts are being worked out, writes Gest, “a group with a powerful vote has thus been neglected, and populists are beginning to take notice.” 

Robert Grano writes from outside Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. His articles and reviews have appeared in Touchstone, Again, and in various small press journals.

Posted: November 5, 2017 in Books in Little.

Did you see this one? book cover

Homo Economicus, Absurdus, or Viator?
Giovanni Patriarca
Fall 2014

A poor man, if he has dignity, honesty, the respect of his neighbors, a realization of his duties, a love of the wisdom of his ancestors, and possibly some taste for knowledge or beauty, is rich in the unbought grace of life.

Russell Kirk

Share

Subscribe & Follow

RSS

More from the Bookman!

book cover book cover book cover


Literature as Counterculture
Allen Mendenhall

The Enigma of the Black Republican
Kareim Oliphant

One Hundred Years of Communism
Francis P. Sempa

The Ambitious Intellectual
Ann-Michele Sproviero

Edwards: From the Beginning of the Right
George H. Nash

The Catholic Novel in an Age of Political Correctness
Trevor C. Merrill


book cover book cover book cover

Bookman Contributors Elsewhere

John Lukacs —the great contemporary historian has pieces in both Chronicles (on being surrounded by books) and First Things (on a displaced pianist).

Joseph Bottom on fraud, American-style.

Andrew Bacevich on the end of endism.

Helen Andrews on the moon landing and the 1970s. Helen (a 2017 Robert Novak Journalism Fellow) wrote one of our most popular pieces, a consideration of the anti-suffragettes.

News

We are pleased to announce the release of The University Bookman on Edmund Burke, now available for Kindle. Collecting 21 reviews, essays, and interviews from the Bookman on the life and thought of Edmund Burke, this book is only $2.99, and purchases support our ongoing work to provide an imaginative defense of the Permanent Things. (3 Mar 2015)

Other Sites of Interest

Publisher Sites

 

Copyright © 2007–2017 The Russell Kirk Center for Cultural Renewal